The Other Race: Guilty Before Being Proven Innocent
You may look into my eyes and think I am guilty. Guilty of vandalizing your homes, stealing money out of your pockets and then smiling at you like nothing has ever happened because that is who I am. Just by a glance, you know that I am an untrustworthy person. I will kidnap your precious babies and loved ones and kill them with no remorse. You fear me because you can see that I am nothing but a criminal, a cold blooded murderer in the making. No one is safe around me. You can tell just by looking at me that I am the other race. People hug their belongings around me because they know what I am. I am Black. And because I am Black, I am guilty.
The bill of rights insures the citizens of America, that in any investigation of the law, the people are always considered innocent before being proven guilty. The people who are involved with the justice system are obligated to uphold this mentality. This notion gives citizens satisfaction that each individual is being treated impartially. Realistically, one’s ideas and beliefs can not be renounced for hours and once again activate when one’s off the clock. At some point, beliefs will entwine with one another. As a result, the suspected individual will already have formulated ideas about their attributes because of how they may appear to be or look. Stereotype has been a major influence in majority of judicial protocol. For the most part, stereotypes used in the judicial system results in negative assumption of the presumed offender; specifically for American Americans. On the contrary, white people have been stereotyped in a more positive manner, which instead of having crucial punishments, they can count on their privileges of being presumed as “good citizens” to assist them. White privilege verses black hindrance due to stereotypes can alter the authorities pursuit of crime.
Privilege
Why does it have to be this way? It all starts with this one word, privilege. According to On Racism and White Privilege “[privilege] provides white people with ‘perks’ that [they] do not earn and that people of color do not enjoy. Second, it creates real advantages for [them]”(Crandall, 2000). Privilege is a social advantage a person is born into. A person does nothing to deserve this advantage they receive over another person, but receives it anyway. Society has constructed general characteristics of certain groups of people. If one belongs to a group and experience advantages for being in that group, they have privilege. Currently, privilege may seem like a harmless concept, but whether or not one has privilege may determine whether or not he or she may get a ticket, stopped or frisked, or if a jury convicts someone or lets them go.
The type of privilege that will be narrowed down to is white privilege. Before I begin to talk about this topic, I know there is a white man or women objecting to this topic saying, “I don't have privilege.” Truth is, every white person has white privilege whether he or she realize it or not. White privilege is not personal. One should not feel guilty because they have white privilege, but they should also not deny the fact they do have it. While I am not putting down white people who have such privilege, I do believe that reformulating our opinions about privilege can help the disadvantaged be less negatively affected by it.
Reasons For The Denial Of White Privilege
White people typically deny the concept of white privilege because they were never taught to acknowledge the fact that they have it, since it is a hard pill to swallow if they had to admit the reason they got through these obstacles was because of their skin color. Most white people have achieved high status in America; they out number any race judicially and politically, and also are widely represented positively in the media. Problematically, in America, people are taught that this social status is a result of how hard one has worked for it—anyone can make it in this country, and if one doesn’t, it’s because one didn't work hard enough. No matter where a person starts financially, theres always an equal opportunity for one to grow.
This “American Dream” illusion is threatened when we recognize white privilege, as it brings doubt into the white man or women who has worked hard to get where they are today. It calls into question if they got as high up as they did because of their hard work or because their fair skin got them that position before they even showed the person their resume. Did they just meet a nice policeman that wouldn't give them that ticket or did their skin complexion take some part in that? Their entire life has nothing to do with hard work, but with the luck of being born into the “right” race. Most people like to look back at their accomplishments and are proud of all of the obstacles they overcame. If color didn't have any weight, someone else of a different race may have taken their position. Thus, denial of privilege by white people is explainable, but no less acceptable.
While successful white people deny their privilege to preserve the value of their accomplishments, poor white people may also deny the fact white privilege exists in the world today. They honestly feel the color of their skin has handed them nothing in this world. Gina Crosley was one of these people. She wrote an article about this issue called Explaining White Privilege to a Broke White Person, where she explained how she had a tough life growing up. She lived in Northern-Illinois with no running water or heat, made ramen noodles in a coffee maker and the water she used was from a public bathroom. When someone told her she had white privilege she was outraged. She thought society did not offer her anything growing up. The feminist who introduced white privilege to Crosley told her to read an article by Peggy McIntosh entitled Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack and after reading she understood the true meaning of being privilege. According to McIntosh, white privilege has nothing to do with the amount of money you have or what class you are in, but to do with the everyday advantage one obtains for being white (Crosley 2014.) One example is the percentage of people being stopped and frisked. According to “Stop and Frisk Data” Out of 77,704 New Yorker, 55 percent were black and nine percent were white. The gap between the blacks and whites being stopped and frisked is enormous and shows that there must be a reason they are stopping colored people more frequently.
The Privilege Of Being Innocent Before Being Proven Guilty
One white privilege that is very concerning to me is how color can determine whether one poses a threat or not in the judicial system. The judicial system should be about evidence and DNA. It should have nothing to do with assumptions. The police who protect and serve our community are human too and from my personal experience all humans have some sort of stereotype about another group of people. This can affect how police treat individuals or a suspects in the working field. Peggy McIntosh used a great example in her article “White Privilege Color and Crime: A Personal Account” she said “I fear police sirens when I am pulled over for speeding, but even then I can observe the processes by which police officers decide to let me off with just a warning. I am a late middle-aged white woman with her hair in a bun who speaks with a soft voice and lives on a well-known street in a mostly white town. I can see the officers’ inclination as they talk to me and look at my license, to feel that I am not as much of a danger on the road as, say, a young black man would be. Yet I think I am every bit as dangerous on the road as the next speeder.”(McIntosh, page 5) This quote really brings out the significance of how stereotypes play a part in white privilege. In her experience, the cops looked at her and knew that she was white. Having a fare skin some how correlates with “abiding the law” and so they assumed she does not pose a threat to society. I know what you maybe thinking how can a fair skin correlated with abiding the law if it is clear she was breaking it? Well, just looking at her skin you can assume she has a good job, a nice house, and is maybe a good person. This causes leniency in the police as they deal with her. They may start to think of her speeding as “a mistake” or “misunderstanding” and as a result, they let her go with a warning. Letting her go with no penalty because she was white not only put Peggy McIntosh in danger, but anyone else who passed by her that night. Letting her go because she's white potentially makes her and every other white person above the law. Rules begin to not to apply, and so they get broken more often. Why should they follow the rules if there is no consequences that they must face? As a result, Accidents begin to rise and so do deaths. According to “Cost of Auto Crashes and Statistics” “In 2012, 10,219 lives were lost due to speed-related accidents, up 2 percent from 10,001 in 2011. In 2010, speeding accounted for 21% of the total economic loss, responsible for as much as $210 billion in costs.” A speeder should be treated like a speeder no matter the color of the person behind the wheel.
The Hindrance Of Being Guilty Before Being Proven Innocent
There is this hypothetical social line that you are either above it and benefit from it or are below it and disadvantage from it and being colored means you have disadvantages in the judicial system. To the judicial system, being colored means being guilty and have to be proven innocent. One well known case written by Sara Burn called “Central park Five” spoke about a white jogger was found almost completely naked in central park. She was unconscious and when the police questioned her she was unaware of what happened. The medics tested her and found that she was raped. This traumatic event touch the heart of many New Yorker and before they knew it, New York City demanded that the police found the rapist. The police picked up 5 young African American boys ranging from ages 13 through 15 and were at the place of the crime scene that day. They all confessed to the raped of the jogger and were convicted to the maximum sentence possible. Years later, a man came up and confessed to the rape of the white jogger and claimed he did it alone. When police tested the mans DNA with the rape kit, it tested positive. The question becomes what went wrong? for starters the children had their rights taken away from them. The children pleaded for their parents and the cops lied and said that they called and their parents were coming for them, when in reality the police never contacted their parents and their parents weren't even aware of what was going on. Secondly, the children were questioned for over 24 hours with no food or water leaving them unable to think properly. Even after the police got a confession out of the children, the police neglected to even test the DNA of the rape kit and the children to make sure it match. How could so little evidence have the jury believe that they were the rapist? the answer is the media. The police relied on the media to paint a picture in the future jurors heads that these were the criminals that rape that young innocent lady. So in the end these children didn't even have a chance. They were guilty before they even walked into trial. Why would the police go out their way to break the law and falsely convict these five boys? was it because they were lazy, and didn't want to catch the real perpetrator?
I believe the reason the police falsely convicted the five boys was the stereotypical belief that all black people are up to no good. This theory runs deep; all the way back to the early 19th century. This was a time where racism was alive and well and stereotypical ideas began to emerge through films. According to Laura Green’s article Negative Racial Stereotypes and Their Effect on Attitudes Toward African-Americans, she uses this great film as an example: “this D.W. Griffith film, the Ku Klux Klan tames the terrifying, savage African- American through lynching. Following emancipation, the image of the threatening brute from the ‘Dark Continent’ was revitalized. Acts of racial violence were justified and encouraged through the emphasis on this stereotype of the Savage. The urgent message to whites was, we must put blacks in their place or else. Old themes about African-Americans began to well up in the face of the perceived threat. Beliefs that blacks were ‘mentally inferior, physically and culturally unevolved, and apelike in appearance’”(Boskin, 1986). Even though there aren't movies like that today, those ideas have been subtly inserted into each generations mind without you being able to detect it. These ideas that African-Americans pose a threat to society is still around today and that is why those police officers falsely convicted these boys. Without recognizing it, the police judged these kids for what they think they were, as oppose to how they really are. These films have influence the idea into the real world that African-Americans act like animals and need to be tamed. It has become a stereotypical burden African-American people must carry over their heads for generation; and probably forever.
Many people like Selwyn Dukes believe there is no such thing as white privilege and that it is a myth. She explained in her article how white people are the one who are disadvantaged in society and African Americans have an advantage. She states “there is also a trove of government programs designed to aid minorities such as those geared toward minority-owned businesses, but no corresponding help for whites. And, as whistleblowers recently revealed, our Department of Justice has long been ignoring voting-rights cases when the victims have been white” (Duke,2011). She doesn't realize it, but she has just made a typical stereotype about African American minorities. If you look on the statistics on statistic brain, it shows that the percentage of African Americans on welfare is 39.8 percent and the percentage of whites on welfare is 38.8 percent. The help given to African American minorities is just as equal as Whites. It is the white privilege that perceives white people are financially stabled so they don’t need any aid. As far as voting rights,
An article from black voices wrote that “One in every three black males born today can expect to go to prison at some point in their life, compared with one in every six Latino males, and one in every 17 white males, if current incarceration trends continue”(2010). With this information one may think that African Americans are the problem. They might make this name for themselves, but the article from black voices show that with an example like selling drugs which only about 13 percent of African Americans participate in, 46 percent of them are convicted for drug offenses. Being black means being targeted more often and harsher than their white peers. The article in american progress stated that even though 30 percent of the population is African African some how 60 percent of them go to jail. It has been proven that African Americans get punished harder for the same crime a white person does in the judicial system (Knafo, 2013.) This means it can’t be black people making a name for themselves. Unfortunately, it seems as though the judicial system is actually after them. As a result, many African Americans have been denied the right to vote because they had prior history in jail.
Solution
From my experience, we as humans like to hear a problem and want to have a solution for it. As much as I would love to see a change in the judicial system, the solution may just be as complicated as the problem. Before we can change the judicial system, we have to first want to change ourselves. I would love to picture a world with no color, but the fact of the matter is that color is the first thing we see in a person. It is almost natural that we formulate people into certain characteristics because of their looks. This can be beneficial to the people who get positive views for how they look, but it really affects the people who are viewed negatively. This is not a natural mind set, but instead taught to us, by some sort of source whether it be media or even your parents. I propose instead of pretending we will never stereotype again, we should practice recognizing when we do stereotype someone because of the color of their skin , and try to diminish the occurrence of stereotyping. This will eventually diminish not only white privilege, but privilege as a whole.
References
Crandall, D. (2000). On Racism and White Privilege. Retrieved May 16, 2015, from http://
www.tolerance.org/article/racism-and-white-privilege
Duke, S. (2011, July 28). Articles: The Myth of White Privilege. Retrieved April 5, 2014,
from http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2011/07 the_myth_of_white_privilege.html
Explaining White Privilege to a Broke White Person. Retrieved April 5, 2015, from http://
www.huffingtonpost.com/gina-crosleycorcoran/explaining-white-privilege-to-a-broke-
white-person_b_5269255.html
Kerby, S. (2012, March 13). The Top 10 Most Startling Facts About People of Color and
Criminal Justice in the United States. Retrieved April 4, 2015, from https://
www.americanprogress.org/issues/race/news/2012/03/13/11351/the-top-10-most-
startling-facts-about-people-of-color-and-criminal-justice-in-the-united-states/
Knafo, S. (2013, October 4). 1 In 3 Black Males Will Go To Prison In Their Lifetime, Report
Warns. Retrieved April 4, 2015, from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/04/!
racial-disparities-criminal-justice_n_4045144.html
Green, L. (n.d.). Stereotypes:Negative Racial Stereotypes and Their Effect on Attitudes Toward
African-Americans. RetrievedApril 5, 2015, from http://www.ferris.edu/news/ jimcrow/links/VCU.htm
McIntosh, P. (1998, January 1). White Privilege, Color and Crime: A Personal Account. Retrieved April 5, 2015, from http://umc-gbcs.org/content/articles/ Undoing_Racism_-_White_Privilege_-_McIntosh.pdf
Stop-and-Frisk Data | New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU) - American Civil Liberties Union of New York State. (n.d.). Retrieved April 5, 2015, from http://!
www.nyclu.org/content/stop-and-frisk-dataCrosley-Corcoran, G. (2014, May 8).
Welfare Statistics. (2014, July 8). Retrieved April 5, 2015, from http:// www.statisticbrain.com/welfare-statistics/







